Cheryl's Cookies

by Mel Aug 19, 2023 | 0 Votes | 83 Bought | 0 Reviews

- rate

Gifts:

Baked Goods Cheryl’s Cookies is an American brick-and-mortar, catalog, and online bakery that specializes in hand-crafted baked goods for everyday and special occasion gifting for delivery nationwide. They are especially known for their buttercream-frosted cookies cut-out in a variety of shapes. Buy Now Similar Sites

People Also Bought

Introduction Gifts to Buy Highlights Overall

Introduction

Cheryl’s Cookies is an American brick-and-mortar, catalog, and online bakery that specializes in hand-crafted baked goods for everyday and special occasion gifting for delivery nationwide. They are especially known for their buttercream-frosted cookies cut-out in a variety of shapes.

Cheryl’s Cookies was founded in 1981 as a small bakery in central Ohio, baking small-batch cookies fresh in store for customers. Then, for a special Valentine’s Day back in the late 80s, Cheryl’s came up with a limited release batch of Valentine’s themed heart-shaped cutout cookies iced with buttercream frosting made with four simple ingredients—butter, vanilla, evaporated milk, and powdered sugar. Instantly popular with customers, these buttercream-frosted cookies soon became Cheryl’s Cookies signature recipe for celebrating life’s delicious moments.

Quickly building a loyal customer base because of its quality fresh-baked desserts using only the finest ingredients, including individually wrapped cookies, brownies and cakes; Cheryl’s expanded its offerings from its original 5 flavors to over 200 cookie and brownie varieties sold at any one time. To date, they bake over 82+ million treats a year, use 9 million lbs. of cookie dough annually, and have released some 1,300 different cookie flavors created in over 40 years.

Today, Cheryl’s Cookies is part of the 1-800-Flowers.com Inc. family of brands, which also includes everyday gifting and sharing products from 1-800-Baskets.com, Shari's Berries, FruitBouquets.com, Harry & David, Moose Munch, PersonalizationMall.com, Simply Chocolate, The Popcorn Factory, and Wolferman’s Bakery.

Gifts to Buy

While Ohio residents and visitors can find Cheryl’s delectable baked goods at their retail stores in select Central Ohio locations, Cheryl’s Cookies’ catalog and website are the easiest ways for customers nationwide to browse their extensive baked goods collections and find the perfect gifts to send to friends, family and loved ones, near and far. Gift baskets, boxes and tins are thoughtfully designed for every season, recipient, and every gifting reason, and come in a range of sizes and gift arrangements that allow you to celebrate one special person or more than one hundred.

Apart from their famous Buttercream Cookies, Cheryl’s also serves up a wide variety of cookies in dozens of flavors, gourmet brownies, cakes, and a host of seasonal items, all made with the finest natural ingredients available. Overall, Cheryl’s Cookies creates over 30 new flavors of cookies and brownies every year so their customers can look forward to sending—and tasting—new goodies each upcoming season along with their favorites.

Meanwhile, you won’t go wrong ordering their All-time Top 5 Flavors such as:

Buttercream Frosted Cut-out Cookies. For over 30 years Cheryl's signature buttercream frosted cookies have become customer favorites. Cheryl’s still bakes their famous cut-out cookies according to their original recipe before hand-icing them with their renowned buttercream frosting. Made from just four ingredients—butter, vanilla, evaporated milk and powdered sugar—this frosting is what keeps Cheryl’s Cookies customers coming back, time after time.

These cut-out cookies change with each season and arrive individually wrapped for easy sharing and can be packed in a wide variety of gift containers. As the years have passed, they’ve added all sorts of delicious flavors like orange citrus, banana walnut, key lime, cinnamon, butter pecan, caramel, peanut butter, chocolate, and more to their original buttercream recipe, but all of them have the same classic rich and creamy texture people crave.

Chocolate Chip. Ever the crowd-pleaser, Cheryl’s chocolate chip cookie is renowned for its balance of richness and sweetness. Their soft and chewy chocolate chip cookie is made with creamery butter, fresh eggs, delicious chocolate chips and rich brown sugar. Each is individually wrapped and guaranteed to please any chocolate chip cookie connoisseur! 12 chocolate chip cookies are carefully packaged and delivered in a bow gift box.

Oatmeal Raisin. Whole rolled oats, plump juicy raisins and just a touch of cinnamon make this classic soft and chewy cookie a customer favorite any time of the year. Cheryl’s mouth-watering recipe was one of the first developed in 1981 and continues to be a favorite every season. Each order of 12 cookies arrives individually wrapped and carefully packaged in a bow gift box.

Snickerdoodle. This classic cinnamon flavored, soft and chewy cookie is made with real butter, brown sugar, wheat flour, fresh eggs and just the right amount of cinnamon - a simple cookie bursting with flavor. Each order of 12 cookies arrives individually wrapped and carefully packaged in a bow gift box.

Chocolate Chocolate Chip. Cheryl’s chocolate lover's delight is made from butter, sugar, and a lot of melted chocolate! Half of the ingredients in this gooey, soft, and chocolaty cookie is chocolate! This melt-in-your-mouth deliciousness is sure to make the chocolate lovers on your list smile! Each box of 12 cookies is individually wrapped for your convenience and can be frozen for quick desserts!

Other Bestsellers include:

Mystery Flavors Cookie Box. Find your favorite with Cheryl’s Mystery Flavors Cookie Box filled with over 8 different individually wrapped varieties for a total of 36 cookies in each box. You might find Old Fashioned Sugar, Chocolate Chip and, of course, their famous Buttercream Frosted Cut-out Cookies (flavors will vary by box). A delicious way to treat yourself!

Throwback Favorites. Two of Cheryl’s Cookies’ favorite flavors are back to celebrate our 40th. When Cheryl’s asked their customers to choose their two absolute favorite Cheryl's cookies of all time, the clear winners were Oatmeal Chocolate Chip and Peanut Butter Chocolate Chunk. In honor of Cheryl’s 40th anniversary, they are bringing back these two old-fashioned favorites for a limited time.

Highlights

Save more when you keep giving the gift of Cheryl’s Cookies with their Celebrations Passport Membership Program. For $19.99 per year, your Passport Program Membership entitles you to special gifts, exclusive perks, and free shipping/no service charge on eligible products and locations. In addition to free shipping, no service charges, and members-only access to special offers, the program now also offers new perks that grow as you gift, exclusive content, and a Celebrations Passport Mobile App that will simplify shopping on the go.

Celebrations Passport has three Membership Tiers:

Gifty (0-499 Points): Includes Free standard shipping/no service charge, exclusive content and gifting tools, and quarterly Celebrations Passport Events featuring great deals on products.

Gifted (500 Points): All of the benefits of Gifty, plus invitations to exclusive events, early access to products and collections, invitations to exclusive events; priority customer service support, and a complimentary birthday gift for you or a friend.

Giftastic (1,200 Points): All of the benefits of Gifted, plus complimentary order upgrade upon tier entry, and a discounted membership renewal.

Earning points is easy. Once you’re a member, you’ll receive points on every purchase at not only Cheryl’s Cookies, but also at 1-800-Flowers.com, Harry & David, FruitBouquets.com, Shari’s Berries, The Popcorn Factory, 1-800-Baskets.com, Simply Chocolate, Wolferman’s Bakery, and Stock Yards. Customers’ gifting tiers are determined based on the points they’ve earned over a 12-month period.

But there are several additional ways to turbocharge your points: make 3 purchases = 50 points; make a purchase in the Celebrations Passport app = 30 points; monthly bonus points for specific purchases defined each month = 30 points; birthday = 50 points; write a review = 15 points; follow Cheryl’s Cookies on social media = 5 points (up to 50 total); and checking out Cheryl’s blog = 5 points.

Overall

If you’re looking for a sweet alternative to gifting the usual flowers and chocolates for your special someone on a special occasion, look no further than Cheryl’s Cookies. Serving up the best buttercream frosting cookies and other delectable baked goods to the whole nation for over 40 years, you can always be assured of top-notch quality, freshness, and taste delivered straight to your doorstep.